CFS views creativity and virtue as two essential tools for solving the problems of the world. To solve a problem, we must have creative solutions and the virtue to carry them through. CFS promotes creativity and virtue by creating an environment in which it is acceptable to make mistakes. Discipline is a supportive, constructive process at CFS. Teacher/student relationships are friendly and collaborative. The staff encourages the students to take risks by trying new things and taking leadership roles. If students believe in themselves and trust that they are supported by their community, they are likely to allow their creativity to go uncensored and to try out embodying virtue, even through mistakes and failures. In this way, CFS promotes creativity and virtue, two essential tools for students to be empowered citizens of society.
Creativity is prized at Friends School. The importance of a healthy body to support a healthy mind is broadly accepted. At CFS, though, dance is celebrated for its own sake. In contrast to what Sir Ken Robinson reported about the tendency of public schools to teach only the head (and slightly to one side), Friends School tries to teach the whole body. We see this in the long lunch we are given to unwind between classes, the much disputed PE requirements, and our teachers' general willingness to let restless students leave class to stretch their legs. We at CFS also value the arts. There are certain limits because most of the students do want to earn admission to a college, which directs the curriculum to a somewhat mainstream selection of required subjects like math, science, social studies, literature and foreign language. Nevertheless, creativity is celebrated when a student finds a new way to answer a math problem, draws an impressive picture, or has a cool idea.
Friends School's mission includes the goal of teaching students that they can, and should, make a positive impact on the world. The teachers at CFS strive to teach students to appreciate the world and the people in it, and to embody virtue--bravery, fairness, generosity--as we engage in that world. From a young age, we Friends School students are taught to think not only of ourselves but also of our friends and classmates. We are told about the world, and paired with children in Afghanistan to write letters. As we grow older, we are shown a fuller picture of what goes on in the world. In the sophomore Global Citizenship Capstone class, my classmates and I were urged to consider whether our complex economic relationships with people in poverty around the world gave us a moral obligation to help them. Different students gave different responses to the question, and our discussion was dynamic. In addition to facilitating theoretical thinking about our world responsibilities, Friends School strives to inspire students to embody virtue by taking action. This is evident in service days, class raise-awareness projects like Susan's class's water bottle wall, and End of Year Trips.
Carolina Friends School provides students with an unusually supportive and engaged community. Students can reflect on the world, express themselves, and try out their virtue on trips and in clubs. Not to mention that if students are unsatisfied with the Upper School experience, we can talk to teachers or Clerks to try to change it. This is one of many ways in which CFS allows students to practice being virtuous, empowered citizens.
Sarah,
ReplyDeleteI have three questions. Firstly, do you feel that we actually accomplish the ideals you have set out? Secondly, if we do accomplish them do we take them far enough? Thirdly, if we do take them far enough do students truly take advantage of the opportunities given to them?
Sarah - this is very interesting, but I would like to have heard more about YOUR personal education, and if you think the CFS system worked for you. Also, as Eric said, does CFS accomplish these things? I forget who said it, maybe Jamie or Mike, but CFS never fully lives up to it's mission statement. Is not living up to its goals part of what makes CFS unique, because it strives to leave the boundaries of mainstream education? I would like to hear your thoughts on this as well, Eric.
ReplyDeleteTo bring the discussion a little more towards Aristole, how does CFS create an "ethos of virtue"? You mention a lot about virtue and creativity and how CFS values them, as well as the teacher/student relationships, but how does CFS use that to encourage students to WANT to seek virtue?
Just some more thoughts. Overall, good job Sarah! Thank you for writing this. And good questions, Eric.
Sarah-
ReplyDeleteWhile your post is interesting and makes me appreciate aspects of the education we gain together at CFS, I would challenge you to further PERSONALLY observe and consider your education at CFS.
Have you carefully separated your own opinions from other people's opinions that you may have heard? Sections of your post seem to accurately describe the mission of CFS, and not necessarily the actual education that you personally experience. perhaps this isn't true- only you can know!
I appreciate the passage referring to your personal experiences (like Capstone class) and would encourage you to shy away from ideals and opinions that you may have unconsciously adopted from the CFS mission statement, or from other people.
Does this make sense? Just something to think about- i admire the eloquence and the thoughtfulness of your post!
emma
This should be on the CFS website or something! Nice work.
ReplyDeleteI agree with the feedback the Emma and kathryn shared. I would have liked see you make personal connections between YOUR education at friends school and Aristotle's and Robinson's philosophy on education.
I have a question to pose...Plato (and to some degree aristotle) argue that justice arises when each is doing his own task, shoemakers making shoes not public policy. Is Robinson's idea that we should all be super creative and unique a contraction of Plato's idea of justice? Isn't creativity something that would get in the way of each person doing his one task, and a industrial, "fast food" model education lead to more students only doing his or her one thing? And therefore that is the best and most just form of education? Of course I am being slightly facetious here and playing the devils advocate, but it's something to consider.
On a side note-I LOVED Robinson's lectures, he is a brilliant speaker, and I wish him luck in his mission to help revolutionize our education system.
Thank you for the feedback everyone!
ReplyDeleteEric--I believe that if students choose to engage in the challenges and questions that CFS sets forth, CFS succeeds in accomplishing its ideals. The ideals, as I understand them, are to get us to start asking questions about our responsibilites as people and to start thinking about how we, as individuals, can embody them in a productive way. I don't think enough students take advantage of the opportunities at CFS, but if they wanted to, they'd get a lot out of it.
I'm not sure whether we take it far enough or not. I certainly feel like I'm in a limbo between my comfortable life and my strong sense of responsibility to help solve the world's problems. If CFS took it farther, maybe I'd be more concretely grounded in the "responsibility" part.
Natalie--
ReplyDeleteEmbodying virtue and creating a space where people feel totally free to be creative is certainly a high-aimed goal. I think it is fair to say that CFS does an unusually great job of these without doing them perfectly.
Ethos is what people do as a group. CFS creates an ethos of virtue by practicing what it preaches. At CFS, we contemplate moral questions. As much as possible, the CFS community engages in the surrounding world in a respectful and hopefully helpful way. The teachers often lead by example, like Jamie inviting us to join him at those events in Durham and taking Susan taking us to Newton Grove in the fall on her own time.
They make us WANT to be virtuous by presenting both logical and emotional connections. Logically, we need to protect the environment for the sake of humanity. Logically, an upper class can't oppress the poor forever. Emotionally, how could we treat that nice poor child that way? These things make me WANT to be virtuous.
In terms of my own experience, I didn't say anything that didn't feel true to my own experience. I could have made that more clear and more specific.
Emma, I think I addressed your comment at the end of my response to Natalie. Were you asking me to use more personal stories? I know that my post probably seemed idealistic, but I experience CFS in a very ideal way sometimes.
ReplyDeleteDan-- On the contrary, I think that Robinson's ideas about children following their creativity fit nicely with Plato's idea of each person following their should.
ReplyDeleteFast Food education herds students of all "shoulds" into one homogenous path. Robinson says that this path leads to being a college professor. If children are allowed to follow their creativity, though, they will inevitably fall in love with a diversity of activities. For example, the fireman certainly followed his should.